3 questions I get all the time
There are a lot of new faces in the Box Pro subscriber universe, so I decided to use this month’s newsletter to get back to basics with three questions I get regularly as a feasibility consultant.
Should I build RV and boat storage or traditional self-storage?
RV and boat storage gets a lot of headlines these days, but the economics are different from traditional self-storage. Traditional storage is more established and may be more prone to overbuilding in some markets. It also generally produces more net operating income per rentable square foot.
I often have clients come to me with an RV and boat storage concept because all the facilities in the market are full and have waiting lists. Is that a good sign? Absolutely. The question is whether enough people will pay the rent you need to make the project pencil, especially if you’re paying traditional self-storage prices for land and construction.
A 12×40 covered RV space renting for $200 a month might sound better than a 10×10 storage unit renting for $100. But the RV space takes up almost five times the rentable area. That’s about 42 cents per square foot per month versus a dollar, before you account for the room people need to actually back a 40-foot RV into the space.
I still like RV and boat storage in the right market. If the land is cheap enough and the site is relatively inexpensive to develop, it can earn a good return.
Why can’t I just put 10% down on an SBA loan?
“My lender says I can finance up to 90% of the project cost, so all I need to put down is 10%!” That can be true, but your project still needs to generate enough cash flow to cover the loan payments with room to spare.
Clients often come to me expecting to put down 10%. Once we run the numbers, sometimes we find that the projected cash flow supports a smaller loan, and they’ll need to put down 15–20% to build the project as planned. At that point, they can bring more cash to the table or we can see whether a smaller project pencils.
What makes a good self-storage site? (Some site selection hot takes)
Population matters more than supply per capita or just about anything else. All else being equal, I like my odds better with more people living within three miles of the site. A low supply-per-capita number looks good on paper, but I still want to know how many potential customers are actually there.
Traffic matters, but its upside is limited. I don’t give a site with 50,000 cars a day much more credit than one with 10,000, assuming both are easy to see and easy to get into.
Beware of the REITs. If your site is close to a Public Storage or an Extra Space, be ready for a potential price war. They can cut move-in rates aggressively when they need to fill units. They may only have a handful of vacancies to fill. You have a whole building. Run the numbers with lower move-in rates during lease-up and see whether you’d still build there.
If you think that’s the extent of my hot takes, you might just need to stay tuned. As always, feel free to reach out to discuss your project.



